Silence settled, broken only by the rain’s patter. Ted didn’t rush to fill it, which irked Ethan for no good reason. He shifted, fingers drumming the armrest, then blurted, “So you just… denied that part of yourself?”
Ted’s expression didn’t change. Ethan had been holding that question since the porch—maybe longer. With no distractions—no phone, no noise—it slipped out.
Ted set his glass down with a quiet thunk, letting the words hang. “I surrendered it,” he said finally. “And I never looked back.”
Ethan scoffed lightly. “That easy, huh?”
Ted’s lips curved, not quite a smile. “Didn’t say it was easy.”
Ethan leaned forward, arms on his knees. “So what—you just decided one day those feelings weren’t real?”
Ted shook his head. “Never said that either.”
Ethan frowned.
Ted exhaled, settling back. “What I’m sayin’ is, I had to choose. The world told me one thing. God told me somethin’ else. I trusted Him more’n I trusted myself.”
Ethan crossed his arms. “And that worked for you?”
Ted nodded, but something heavier flickered in his eyes. He stared into the lantern’s glow. “I almost didn’t,” he admitted.
Ethan raised an eyebrow.
Ted rubbed his jaw, exhaling through his nose. “For a while, I figured I’d got it wrong. Maybe I was holdin’ onto somethin’ outta fear. So I walked away—gave the world’s way a shot, thought I’d find what I was lookin’ for.”
Ethan’s stomach tightened. He hadn’t expected this.
Ted shook his head, gaze settling on him. “Didn’t. Lost more’n I care to admit.” He leaned forward. “You wanna know why I trust God more’n myself? I’ve seen what happens when I don’t.”
Ted sipped his water, calm again. “Spent years thinkin’ I had to choose between bein’ loved and bein’ faithful. But I was askin’ the wrong question. It wasn’t about that—it was about choosin’ Him.”
Ethan swallowed, throat tight. He forced a smirk. “Not many people sound as sure as you.”
“Took a long time to get here,” Ted said, a quiet laugh in his voice.
Ethan watched him, the lantern light carving deeper lines in his face. He should’ve argued, laughed it off. But he didn’t want to. That scared him more than anything.
Ted stood, grabbing a blanket from a closet and draping it over the couch. “In case it gets cold tonight.”
(Excerpt from Narrow Road Together in the Ethan & Ted series. Contact me if you’d like to read the full story)